Real Estate Reviews: Ask for an Honest Account, Not Five Stars
Use a neutral post-closing review request. Distinguish prohibited rewards for positive reviews from incentives that need disclosure and platform approval.
Ask actual clients for an honest account of the service they received, without a reward or a requested rating. If the brokerage does offer something of value, it cannot condition that incentive, expressly or by implication, on a positive or negative review. Disclosing a gift doesn't make buying five stars permissible.
Two different questions about the same gift card
Suppose an agent drafts this after closing: “Tell everyone how much you loved our service and I'll send a $25 coffee card.” There is no star count in the message, but the wording ties the card to praise. The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule Q&A, section 465.4 explains that an implied sentiment condition counts too.
Changing the offer to “$25 for any honest review, favorable or not” removes that condition. It doesn't settle everything else. FTC guidance distinguishes the rule's sentiment ban from the risk of misleading people under the FTC Act by failing to disclose an incentive. Check the platform first; if it bars incentivized reviews, don't run the offer there. If permitted and broker-approved, ask the client to make the connection clear in the review itself: “The brokerage offered me a $25 card for writing an honest review, regardless of my rating.” A note in your private email doesn't inform the reader.
A request an agent can send without an incentive
Thank you for working with me on the sale. If you'd like to leave a review, what was useful about our weekly updates, and what could I have done better? Here's the review link. Please leave out the buyer's details and anything you'd rather keep private.
Use the same invitation at the same milestone, not a survey that sends happy clients to the public site and everyone else to a private inbox. Don't post a suggested testimonial in the client's voice. If you later quote the review in your agent marketing, get permission, preserve its meaning and keep any material incentive disclosure with the quote. A reader seeing the excerpt shouldn't need to find the original review to understand who paid whom.
Ready to save hours on listing marketing?
Upload your listing photos and get an MLS description, social posts, and PDF flyer — every word Fair Housing scanned — in under 60 seconds.
Create your first kit free