Tenant Screening: What Goes in the Ad, the Criteria and the Decision Notice?

Separate rental marketing from written screening criteria. Learn why approving an applicant with a co-signer can still trigger an adverse action notice.

A rental ad describes the unit and how to apply. Published screening criteria explain how applications will be evaluated. An adverse action notice tells an individual applicant about a decision influenced by a consumer report. Linking the criteria in the ad doesn't satisfy the notice obligation, and a neutral-sounding ad can't fix inconsistent screening behind it.

Before accepting applications: explain the process

List the rent, availability, verified features and a clear route to the current criteria. Avoid descriptions of a preferred occupant. Have the responsible housing provider review the criteria for fair housing, lawful sources of income, accommodations and local restrictions before using them. Date the criteria and give applicants the same version; don't invent a new hurdle once you see a name or family composition.

Local example: Seattle's first-in-time guidance calls for advance notice of minimum screening criteria, necessary documentation and the right to request additional time in specified circumstances. Don't assume that Seattle's application-order process is national law. For the marketing copy itself, see the fair housing guide to rental listings.

After the report: an approval can still be adverse

Suppose you're helping a landlord process an application. A third-party tenant screening report influences the landlord to require a co-signer who would not otherwise have been required. The applicant can still rent, so the landlord wants to send a simple congratulations email. Stop and check the basis for the changed terms. Under the FTC's Fair Credit Reporting Act guidance for landlords, a co-signer requirement based even partly on a consumer report is an adverse action. It doesn't have to be an outright rejection.

Have the decision-maker give the required notice. Identify the reporting agency by name, address and phone number; explain that it didn't make the decision and can't give the specific reasons. Include the right to dispute accuracy or completeness and to request a free copy from that agency within 60 days. Use the additional written or electronic disclosures required if a credit score was used, and check state or local requirements. A vendor's generic “application processed” email isn't evidence the applicant received the right notice.

Keep the applicable criteria, decision basis and notice record in the restricted application file, not in MLS notes. If the applicant reports a mistaken identity, direct them to the dispute process rather than promising that the screening company can reverse the landlord's decision.

Check your description for Fair Housing violations

Scan any listing description against 8 protected classes. See your risk score free; leave an email to unlock exact phrases, fixes, and a cleaned version.

Run the free checker