Dual Agency in New York: What Both Clients Give Up

Use a New York residential sale to distinguish acknowledgment from informed written consent, and a factual showing question from negotiation advice.

In a New York residential sale covered by Real Property Law §443, a broker may represent both buyer and seller only with both parties' informed written consent. Dual agency changes the advice the clients can expect: neither gets the broker's undivided loyalty. A buyer walking into the listing agent's open house doesn't, by that act alone, agree to dual representation.

Listen for the question that changes the conversation

Suppose you represent the seller of a New York single-family house. An unrepresented visitor asks when the roof was replaced. You can share the verified invoice date while making clear whom you represent. Then the visitor asks, “Will you represent me and tell me what to offer so they'll take it?” The seller privately told you they'd accept less than the asking price. Don't answer the strategy question from that information or invite the buyer to confide their ceiling.

Instead, pause and explain the choices with your supervising broker. The buyer can seek independent representation. If your brokerage offers dual agency and both parties want it, explain the conflict to each before proceeding. A useful seller question is: “When the buyer wants help getting the lowest price, what advice will you no longer be able to give either of us?” If either party declines, don't proceed as a dual agent.

The New York Department of State's Real Estate License Law, §443 includes the buyer-and-seller disclosure form. It distinguishes acknowledgment of receipt from advance informed consent, and separately addresses dual agency with designated sales agents. Don't find a signature at the bottom of an old disclosure and assume it authorizes today's arrangement. Check which relationship was disclosed, which consent was given and whether it covers the actual parties and circumstances.

In the file, record the roles, explanation, decisions and forms, not just “buyer attended open house.” In the offer presentation, avoid representing that you can bargain exclusively for each side. This is a New York example; don't export its forms or consent procedure to another state.

Ready to save hours on listing marketing?

Upload your listing photos and get an MLS description, social posts, and PDF flyer — every word Fair Housing scanned — in under 60 seconds.

Create your first kit free