A Seller’s Agent: What Loyalty Looks Like When Two Offers Arrive

Distinguish a seller’s confidential bargaining position from property facts, and show the seller how competing offers serve their own priorities.

A seller's agent represents the seller's interests in the transaction. That means protecting the seller's bargaining position, bringing forward information that matters to their choice and following lawful instructions. It doesn't mean accepting an offer for the seller, concealing material property facts or recommending whichever buyer makes the agent's work easier.

The seller's-agent section of New York's statutory agency disclosure form, Real Property Law §443, names reasonable care, undivided loyalty, confidentiality, full disclosure, obedience and a duty to account. It also calls for honest, fair dealings with the buyer and disclosure of known material property facts except as otherwise provided by law. This is a seller-only representation example in a covered New York residential transaction. Local law and the agency agreement govern elsewhere.

One private instruction, two different offers

Suppose your seller needs possession through June 15 while a replacement home is completed. They privately authorize you to explore a lower price if it secures that date. Offer A is $510,000 with vacant possession June 1. Offer B is $505,000 with vacant possession June 17. You're about to leave for vacation; A's buyer wants an answer today.

Bring both offers to the seller with the actual price, deadlines, conditions and possession dates. Ask what temporary housing and a second move would mean if they choose A, and whether they want to counter on possession. Don't reveal their minimum price to B, tell A the seller is desperate, or rush the decision to suit your calendar. The seller may prefer the lower number for a reason that matters more than the $5,000 difference. Record their choice and communicate only the terms they authorize.

Loyalty doesn't turn a defect into a secret

Change one fact: the buyer asks about water entering the basement, and you have the seller's repair record. Their private motivation for moving and the property's history are different kinds of information. Don't volunteer the former or dismiss the latter as confidential. Verify the facts and consult the broker about the applicable disclosure duty before answering. For an ordinary multiple-offer comparison, the worksheet handles price and timing; the fiduciary question is whose interests guide what you do with it.

Ready to save hours on listing marketing?

Upload your listing photos and get an MLS description, social posts, and PDF flyer — every word Fair Housing scanned — in under 60 seconds.

Create your first kit free